Antitrust Regulators Move To Block ICE’s $11.7B Black Knight Acquisition | Inman
In these occasions, double down — in your expertise, in your information, on you. Be part of us August 8-10 at Inman Join Las Vegas to lean into the shift and study from one of the best. Get your ticket now for one of the best value.
Federal antitrust regulators have moved to dam Intercontinental Trade Inc.’s pending $11.7 billion acquisition of actual property software program, knowledge and analytics supplier Black Knight, saying the deal would put an finish to intense competitors between the 2 firms and drive up prices for lenders and homebuyers.
Intercontinental Trade (ICE) owns the preferred mortgage origination system (LOS) utilized by U.S. mortgage lenders, Embody. Black Knight owns the second-largest mortgage origination system, Empower.
Antitrust regulators have been scrutinizing the deal since at the least final June when the Federal Commerce Fee (FTC) despatched ICE and Black Knight a “second request” for extra info and paperwork.
ICE and Black Knight had hoped to appease the FTC, saying Tuesday that they’d reached an settlement to promote Empower to Constellation Internet Options. The FTC shattered these hopes Thursday by launching an administrative continuing to dam the merger.
“By eliminating Black Knight as a competitor, the deal would free ICE to extra aggressively increase costs that it expenses mortgage lenders for origination providers,” the FTC mentioned in saying a 4-0 vote to provoke a continuing earlier than an administrative regulation decide.
In a press release, ICE mentioned it “strongly disagrees with, and can vigorously oppose” the FTC’s problem.
“ICE is totally assured in our place and appears ahead to presenting it in courtroom,” the corporate mentioned. “Whereas that litigation performs out, the corporate is continuous its work towards closing the acquisition, which it expects to finish within the third or fourth quarter of this 12 months.”
In its grievance, the FTC mentioned its assessment of inside ICE paperwork revealed the usage of a number of “levers” to develop income, together with value will increase to Embody clients.
Along with mortgage origination programs, mortgage lenders depend on many suppliers of “ancillary providers,” similar to doc distributors, borrower point-of-sale and product and pricing engines (PPEs) that generate mortgage pricing based mostly on borrower standards.
The FTC dismissed Black Knight’s proposal to promote Empower to Constellation Internet Options as a treatment, noting that Constellation would function a reseller of ancillary providers to be offered by ICE, together with Black Knight’s Optimum Blue mortgage product and pricing engine (PPE).
“Black Knight’s Optimum Blue is the clear business chief, serving lenders that originate as a lot as 40 % of the nation’s residential mortgages every year,” FTC attorneys mentioned of their grievance. “Second to Optimum Blue is its shut competitor, ICE’s Embody Product and Pricing Service PPE (“EPPS”), at the moment out there solely to lenders who use the Embody LOS.”
Constellation Internet Options is a subsidiary of Constellation Software program Inc., a publicly traded firm based mostly in Toronto with a market capitalization of $34.9 billion ($48 billion Canadian) and the father or mother firm of U.S.-based Constellation Mortgage Options (CMS).
However as a result of Black Knight wouldn’t be transferring a standalone enterprise, the FTC alleges Constellation Internet Options would lack the “potential, sources and incentive to interchange the depth of the competitors between ICE and Black Knight.”
‘Ongoing development’ towards consolidation
The FTC mentioned it’s additionally nervous that if the deal have been to undergo, it “might speed up an ongoing development towards vertical integration and consolidation” in mortgage know-how.
ICE added Embody to its steady of merchandise by means of its $11.4 billion acquisition of Ellie Mae in 2020. That deal was preceded by ICE’s 2016 acquisitions of Mortgage Digital Registration Methods Inc. (MERS), a database monitoring mortgage mortgage possession, and Simplifile, an e-recording and shutting software program agency ICE acquired in 2019.
Along with Empower, Black Knight’s mortgage know-how merchandise embody mortgage servicing platform Compass Analytics, which Black Knight purchased in 2019, and Optimum Blue, which Black Knight acquired in 2020.
“Each ICE and Black Knight are traditionally acquisitive firms,” the FTC mentioned. “ICE plans to proceed an business development towards consolidation and vertical integration by buying Black Knight’s varied ancillary providers to spherical out ICE’s personal choices. As ICE accumulates extra ancillary providers, its incentive to drawback third-party distributors will improve as its must do enterprise with third events who at the moment present these providers to customers of Embody and Empower will diminish.”
ICE and Black Knight have maintained that the merger would permit them to create a “lifetime of mortgage” mortgage platform with cost-saving efficiencies that will profit shoppers.
‘Lifetime of mortgage’ mortgage platform
ICE envisions constructing a “lifetime of mortgage” mortgage platform by integrating know-how constructed by Black Knight with its personal options. | Supply: Could 5, 2022 ICE investor presentation
In a 2022 investor presentation, ICE claimed advantages to homebuyers would come with:
- Digitization and automation of mortgage originations, decreasing prices for all events
- Surfacing knowledge to assist present householders perceive new money-saving mortgage packages
- Eliminating inaccurate charges and decreasing prices for shoppers by linking mortgage origination and servicing programs
- Connecting lenders with potential consumers in traditionally underserved markets by integrating origination and servicing knowledge
- Decreased minority bias in house valuations
Tim Bowler, president of ICE Mortgage Expertise, sounded an identical word Thursday.
“We’re upset that the FTC has filed litigation to stop ICE from closing our acquisition of Black Knight,” Bowler mentioned in a press release. “The proposed acquisition can deliver to life a real end-to-end answer for the mortgage business, benefitting aspiring and present householders throughout the US.”
However the FTC mentioned it expects the merger would disproportionately hurt lower-income and first-time homebuyers if lenders find yourself paying greater prices for mortgage origination programs and ancillary providers like mortgage merchandise and pricing engines.
These prices “possible might be handed on to shoppers within the type of greater mortgage origination prices,” the FTC alleged.
“On condition that origination prices stay comparatively fixed whatever the quantity of a mortgage, a rise in origination prices will lead to a proportionally bigger value improve for a homebuyer searching for a $200,000 mortgage than for a homebuyer that may afford a $1,000,000 mortgage,” FTC attorneys mentioned of their grievance.
“Equally, elevated origination prices will have an effect on homebuyers who should finance their house purchases to a larger diploma than wealthier homebuyers who might pay money. Put merely, greater origination prices will disproportionately hurt lower-income and first-time homebuyers.”
Attorneys for ICE and Black Knight have 14 days to reply the FTC’s grievance, whose allegations might be tried in a proper listening to earlier than an administrative regulation decide.
Get Inman’s Further Credit score E-newsletter delivered proper to your inbox. A weekly roundup of all the largest information on the planet of mortgages and closings delivered each Wednesday. Click on right here to subscribe.
E mail Matt Carter